Image by Rotten Tomatoes

On December 31, 2025 The Duffer Brothers came out with the long awaited finale of the beloved Netflix original ‘Stranger Things’. Upon the release of the finale however, many were left largely disappointed; a fan favorite turned out to be a major let down. So much so that some fans believed that there would be a ‘secret’ ninth episode that would be released on January 7, 2026; but of course, there was no hidden episode nine and we are met with the end of Stranger Things and fans are left unsatisfied with their favorite show (for more information on the Conformity Theory check out ‘Conformity Gate: How Expectations Opens the Door to Disappointment’ by Jake Malan). However, though the Duffer Brothers left quite a few strings untied at the end, they captured the nostalgia of the show perfectly. Flashbacks and references to earlier seasons throughout both volumes of season 5.

One of the main reasons fans were unhappy with the ending were the plethora of plot holes and mishaps in the series. Even by the end, they failed to tie off the ending and give plausible explanations to certain parts of the show. For example, in the cave where Henry was reliving his ‘villain arc’, the first time he was exposed to the Mind Flayer, we are never really told how it all started. Where did this matter come from?

Additionally, fans were confused about the fact that Will was left unaffected when Vecna was killed even though he was still connected to the hive mind– a connection that was created between Will and the creatures of the Upside Down while he was trapped there in the first season– at the time. This inconsistency felt especially jarring because Will’s connection to the Upside Down has been one of the most carefully developed throughlines of the series since season one. By choosing not to address it directly, the finale undermined years of emotional and narrative buildup, leaving viewers to fill in the gaps themselves rather than providing a satisfying resolution.

Another major criticism of the finale was its rushed pacing. With so many characters to service and arcs to conclude, the final episodes often felt overcrowded, prioritizing spectacle over substance. Emotional moments that should have been highlighted (final goodbyes, long-awaited reunions, and the consequences of the battle) were quickly glossed over in favor of moving the plot forward. As a result, some character endings felt unearned, especially for side characters who had grown into fan favorites over the years.

That being said, the finale was not without its strengths. The Duffer Brothers excelled at capturing the heart of Stranger Things: the bond between friends, the fear and wonder of growing up, and the bittersweet nature of endings. The callbacks to earlier seasons—bikes racing down quiet suburban streets, synth-heavy music, and parallel shots to season one—were undeniably effective. These moments served as a reminder of why audiences fell in love with the show in the first place, even if the overall conclusion fell short.

Ultimately, the Stranger Things finale is a mixed ending to an otherwise iconic series. While it succeeds in delivering nostalgia and emotional resonance, it struggles to provide narrative closure and clear answers to long-standing questions. For many fans, the disappointment stems not from a lack of effort, but from the sense that a show with such rich storytelling potential deserved a more carefully tied conclusion. Stranger Things may not have ended perfectly, but its impact on pop culture—and on the fans who grew up alongside it—will undoubtedly remain.